• Menu
  • Product
  • Email
  • PDF
  • Order now
  • Advantages and Challenges of Multi-RoleMulti-Channel versus Single-Channel

    • SWRA733 March   2022 WL1807MOD , WL1837MOD

       

  • CONTENTS
  • SEARCH
  • Advantages and Challenges of Multi-RoleMulti-Channel versus Single-Channel
  1.   Trademarks
  2.   Acronyms
  3. 1Introduction
  4. 2 Single-Channel Versus Multi-Channel
    1. 2.1 MRSC Single Radio Network Topology
    2. 2.2 MRMC Single Radio Network Topology
    3. 2.3 Experiment and Results
  5. 3Multi-Channel Challenges and Requirements
    1. 3.1 802.11 Spec Enablers for Role Switch Protections
    2. 3.2 Role Switch Protection Implementations
      1. 3.2.1 AP Based Roles
      2. 3.2.2 STA Based Roles
    3. 3.3 Single Radio Multi-Channel Challenges
    4. 3.4 Single Radio Multi-Channel Key Requirements
  6. 4WL18xx™ Multi-Channel Implementations
    1. 4.1 Arranging the Role Activity Requests by Priority
    2. 4.2 Scheduling the Role Activities
    3. 4.3 Leveraging MRMC to Improve WLAN-BT Coexistence
  7. 5Conclusions
  8.   Appendix
  9. IMPORTANT NOTICE
search No matches found.
  • Full reading width
    • Full reading width
    • Comfortable reading width
    • Expanded reading width
  • Card for each section
  • Card with all content

 

TECHNICAL WHITE PAPER

Advantages and Challenges of Multi-RoleMulti-Channel versus Single-Channel

Trademarks

Wi-Fi is a trademark of Wi-Fi Alliance.

WiLink, WL18xx, and AM335x are trademarks of Texas Instruments.

Bluetooth is a registered trademark of Bluetooth SIG.

All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Acronyms

ACK Acknowledgment
AP Access Point
BT Bluetooth
BW Bandwidth
CH Channel
CL Client
DUT Device Under Test
DTIM Delivery Traffic Indication Message
GO Group Owner
MIMO Multiple Input Multiple Output
MRSC Multi Role Single Channel
MRMC Multi Role Multi Channel
P2P Peer to Peer
PS Power Save
SISO Single Input Single Output
STA Station
SP Service Period
WLAN Wireless Local Area Network

1 Introduction

Legacy WLAN implementations assume a single WLAN role operation (station, access point or any other WLAN role). Multi Role means that several WLAN roles (two or more) are operating concurrently, on the same or even different channels and/or bands.

A typical example for Multi Role can be a gateway device where one role is a WLAN station connected to home access point which provides the access to the internet, and the other role is a WLAN access point connected to one or more sensors scattered around the house. In such a system a user can access the gateway device to easily monitor and control each one of the sensors instead of accessing one by one.

GUID-20220120-SS0I-NJWW-KZQW-BCLXLXV83ZPL-low.jpgFigure 1-1 Multi Role Example

One approach is to implement concurrency using two or more completely separate radio systems (for example, one per each role). This fits the high-end, highest-performance, and most expensive solution.

On the other hand, for more cost-effective solutions – a single radio system (for example, radio and SW controller) manages transitions between multiple roles. With the single radio approach, the concurrency can be implemented using time-division sharing of system resources and thus achieve a more cost-effective solution. In such single radio solutions, the Multi Role implementation can be limited to operate all roles on the same physical channel (“Single-Channel” Multi Role) or allow the different roles to operate on different channels (“Multi-Channel” Multi Role).

This paper presents the multi-channel approach advantages over a single-channel approach of such multi-role solutions from an overall system performance point-of-view. This paper also discusses the challenges of achieving a cost-effective multi-role multi-channel solution with a single radio, and describes the different solutions that ensure a stable, high performing and reliable system as implemented in TI WL18xx™.

2 Single-Channel Versus Multi-Channel

As mentioned, a Multi Role solution implements several WLAN roles operating concurrently. There are different multi role types and each one has different properties: The single channel type limiting the WLAN roles to operate on same band and channel (for example AP and STA operating on channel 1 on the 2.4-GHz band). The multi-channel type, on the other hand, can avoid this by allowing the WLAN roles to operate on different channels and even bands.

Another aspect is the amount of radios used for the multi-role solution. The multiple radios solution can achieve full concurrency where each WLAN role gets its own resources and full radio access. The single radio solution can achieve similar system efficiency and performance by dividing the radio access and resources in a managed way and overcome some of the challenges.

 

Texas Instruments

© Copyright 1995-2025 Texas Instruments Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Submit documentation feedback | IMPORTANT NOTICE | Trademarks | Privacy policy | Cookie policy | Terms of use | Terms of sale