Space-Grade, 100-krad, Window Comparator Circuit

Design Goals

Input Supply	Comparator Output Status (OUT)		Radiation
Operating Range	26V ≤ V_in ≤ 30V	V_in < 26V or V_in > 30V	Total Ionizing Dose (TID)	SEL Immunity to LET
20 V to 36 V	V_out = V_pu	V_out = GND	100 krad(Si)	85 MeV·cm²/mg

Design Description

This application brief shows how to implement a voltage window comparator circuit, targeted to monitor a 28-V power rail, a spacecraft bus voltage commonly found in smaller aircraft. This wide single-supply window comparator circuit utilizes a dual open-collector comparator and 3 resistors to set the window voltage. A shunt regulator, TL1431-SP, is used to provide a reference voltage from the input voltage. Therefore, only a single power supply is utilized for the input portion of the circuit. The LM193AQML-SP was used for its open collector output, radiation specifications, and two channel count. Whenever the input voltage, V_in, is within the window of comparison (26 V to 30 V), the output of the circuit, V_OUT, is high. Whenever Vin is outside of the window of comparison, the V_OUT is pulled down to GND.

Design Notes

Select a high-voltage comparator with an open collector output stage.
Select a comparator with low input offset voltage to optimize accuracy.
Calculate values for the resistor divider so that V_OUT goes high whenever V₁ crosses V_REF and goes low whenever V₂ crosses V_REF.
Calculate R5 such that shunt regulator is within sink current specification for entire operating range.

Design Steps

Select a high-voltage comparator with an open collector output stage that can operate at the highest possible supply voltage. In this design, the highest input/supply voltage is 36 V.
Determine an appropriate reference level, V_REF, for the window comparator. The TL1431-SP internal reference voltage, 2.5 V, was used for ease of calculations. If another reference voltage were to be used with the TL1431-SP, a voltage divider would be needed between the cathode and anode of the shunt regulator, with V_REF between the resistors.
Calculate the value of R₅, the resistor across V_IN and V_REF, by relating V_REF to the operating voltage range. Ensure that R₅ is at a level where the shunt regulator is sufficiently biased for the entire operating range. The current needed to bias the TL1431-SP, I_Bias, has to be between 1 mA and 100 mA. A 4.7-kΩ resistor was chosen as it kept the bias current within this range for the entire voltage operating range.
Equation 1. $I_{Bias (Min)} = \frac{V_{in (Min)} - V_{Ref}}{R_{5}} = \frac{20 V - 2.5 V}{4.7 kΩ} = 3.72 mA$
Equation 1. $I_{Bias (Max)} = \frac{V_{in (Max)} - V_{Ref}}{R_{5}} = \frac{36 V - 2.5 V}{4.7 kΩ} = 7.12 mA$
Values between 350 Ω and 16 kΩ could be used in this design. Consideration was made to minimize the bias current, yet give some buffer from the 1 mA minimum specification. If V_REF is seen to be noisy, a decoupling capacitor can be placed between the node and GND to filter out the noise.
The positive input to the top comparator, V₁, and the negative input to the bottom comparator, V₂, can be related to V_in through voltage division:
Equation 1. $V_{1} = V_{in} (\frac{R_{2} + R_{3}}{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}}), V_{2} = V_{in} (\frac{R_{3}}{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}})$
The window comparator trips when V₁ passes V_REF to output high, and again when V₂ passes V_REF to output low. The comparator is low if V₁ is less than V_REF. In this design, the window comparator will trip high when V_in equals 26 V and trip low when V_in equals 30 V; both while V_REF equals 2.5 V.
Equation 1. $2.5 = 26 (\frac{R_{2} + R_{3}}{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}}) \to 10.4 = \frac{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}}{R_{2} + R_{3}}$
Equation 1. $2.5 = 30 (\frac{R_{3}}{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}}) \to 12 = \frac{R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}}{R_{3}}$
Solve both equations from step 4 for (R₁+R₂+R₃) and substitute one equation for the other.
Equation 1. $10.4 R_{2} + 10.4 R_{3} = R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}$
Equation 1. $12 R_{3} = R_{1} + R_{2} + R_{3}$
Equation 1. $12 R_{3} = 10.4 R_{2} + 10.4 R_{3}$
Equation 1. $10.4 R_{2} = 1.6 R_{3} \to 6.5 R_{2} = R_{3}$
Using the relationship obtained in step 5, solve for a relationship between R₁ and R₂.
Equation 1. $12 (6.5 R_{2}) = R_{1} + R_{2} + 6.5 R_{2}$
Equation 1. $78 R_{2} = R_{1} + 7.5 R_{2} \to 70.5 R_{2} = R_{1}$
Using the equations derived in steps 5 and 6, size resistors R₁, R₂, and R₃ accordingly. For this design, R₂ was set to be 2.55 kΩ, which meant R₁ and R₃ would be 179.775 kΩ and 16.575 kΩ, respectively. The magnitude of these resistors were chosen based off of the current consumption across the voltage divider (around 100 to 180 μA across the operating condition).
Select a 5% tolerant resistor to act as the pullup resistor, R₄, from the output of the window comparator to V_PU. Size this component large enough to ensure the current sinked by the comparator is not large, but small enough that the leakage current drawn by the comparator output when high is not causing too large of a voltage drop.
The values obtained in step 7 were adjusted for 1% resistor tolerances to be 178 kΩ, 2.55 kΩ, and 16.5 kΩ for R₁, R₂, and R₃, respectively. Due to these changes, the window of comparison was shifted to trip earlier for overvoltage conditions and later for undervoltage conditions. In the DC Simulation Results, the window of comparison is between 25.8595 V and 29.856 V.

Design Simulations

DC Simulation Results

Transient Simulation Results

References:

SPICE Simulation File: http://www.ti.com/lit/zip/snom708.

Design Featured Comparator

LM193QML-SP
V_S	2 V to 36 V
V_inCM	0 V to 34.5 V
V_OUT	Open-Collector
V_OS	5 mV
I_Q	200 μA/channel
t_PD(HL)	2.50 μs
TID Radiation Lot Acceptance Test (RLAT) / RHA	100 krad(Si)
TID Characterization (ELDRS-Free)	100 krad(Si)
SEL Immune to LET	SEL Immune (Bipolar process)
http://www.ti.com/product/LM193QML-SP

Design Featured Shunt Reference

TL1431-SP
V_KA	2.5 V to 36 V
I_KA	1 mA to 100 mA
V_I(ref)	2.5 V
Initial Accuracy	0.4%
TID	100 krad(Si)
SEL Immune to LET	SEL Immune (Bipolar process)
www.ti.com/product/TL1431-SP

Design Alternate Comparator

	TLV1704-SEP	LM139AQML-SP
V_S	2.2 V to 36 V	2 V to 36 V
V_inCM	Rail-to-rail	0 V to 34 V
V_OUT	Open-Collector, Rail-to-rail	Open-Collector
V_OS	500 µV	2 mV
I_Q	55 µA/channel	200 μA/channel
t_PD(HL)	460 ns	2.50 μs
TID Characterization (ELDRS-Free)	30 krad(Si)	100 krad(Si)
TID Radiation Lot Acceptance Test (RLAT) / RHA	20 krad(Si)	100 krad(Si)
SEL Immune to LET	43 MeV·cm²/mg	SEL Immune (Bipolar process)
	https://www.ti.com/product/TLV1704-SEP	https://www.ti.com/product/LM139AQML-SP

IMPORTANT NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER

TI PROVIDES TECHNICAL AND RELIABILITY DATA (INCLUDING DATASHEETS), DESIGN RESOURCES (INCLUDING REFERENCE DESIGNS), APPLICATION OR OTHER DESIGN ADVICE, WEB TOOLS, SAFETY INFORMATION, AND OTHER RESOURCES “AS IS” AND WITH ALL FAULTS, AND DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS AND IMPLIED, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR NON-INFRINGEMENT OF THIRD PARTY INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS.

These resources are intended for skilled developers designing with TI products. You are solely responsible for (1) selecting the appropriate TI products for your application, (2) designing, validating and testing your application, and (3) ensuring your application meets applicable standards, and any other safety, security, or other requirements. These resources are subject to change without notice. TI grants you permission to use these resources only for development of an application that uses the TI products described in the resource. Other reproduction and display of these resources is prohibited. No license is granted to any other TI intellectual property right or to any third party intellectual property right. TI disclaims responsibility for, and you will fully indemnify TI and its representatives against, any claims, damages, costs, losses, and liabilities arising out of your use of these resources.

TI’s products are provided subject to TI’s Terms of Sale (www.ti.com/legal/termsofsale.html) or other applicable terms available either on ti.com or provided in conjunction with such TI products. TI’s provision of these resources does not expand or otherwise alter TI’s applicable warranties or warranty disclaimers for TI products.