P-FET based reverse polarity protection is a very
commonly used scheme in automotive applications to achieve low insertion loss
protection solution. A low loss reverse polarity protection solution can be realized
using the LM74501-Q1 with an external N-FET to replace P-FET based solution. The
LM74501-Q1-based reverse polarity protection solution offers input TVS-less
performance during ISO7637-2 pulse 1 event, better cold crank performance (low VIN
operation) and smaller solution size compared to P-FET based solution. Figure 9-1 compares the
performance benefits of LM74501-Q1 + N-FET over a traditional P-FET based reverse
polarity protection solution.
As shown in Figure 9-1, a given
power level LM74501-Q1 + N-FET solution can be 50% smaller than a similar power
rated P-FET solution.
The second advantage that the LM74501-Q1 offers
over a traditional P-FET is TVS-less operation for the body control module load
driving paths where reverse current blocking is not a must-have feature and
output loads are capable of handling negative voltage and reverse current for a
short duration of the time.
As PFET is self biased by simply pulling its gate
pin low, P-FET shows poorer cold crank performance (low VIN operation) compared
to the LM74501-Q1. During severe cold crank where battery voltage falls below 4
V, P-FET series resistance increases drastically as shown in Figure 9-1. This
increase leads to higher voltage drop across the PFET. Also, with a higher
gate-to-source threshold (VT), this can sometimes lead to system
reset due to turning off of the P-FET. On the other side, the LM74501-Q1 has
excellent severe cold crank performance. The LM74501-Q1 keeps the external FET
completely enhanced even when input voltage falls to 3.2 V during severe cold
crank operation.
Figure 9-1 PFET vs LM74501-Q1 Reverse Polarity Protection Solution Comparison