This article appeared in Electronic Design and has been published here with permission.
Ethernet has become a mainstream communications protocol, at the top of the control pyramid in building automation. Recently, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) defined a new Ethernet standard, IEEE 802.3.cg for 10 Mb/s operation and associated power delivery over a single balanced pair of conductors. Because a single-pair cable can now support both data and power, adoption of the standard can lead to significant cost savings and easier installation in building automation applications.
There are numerous efforts to take Ethernet to the edge devices. Multiple communication networks currently exist in building automation – for example, heating, ventilation and air-conditioning (HVAC) applications use Modbus, access control uses BACnet, lighting uses LonWorks and fire safety uses Ethernet. This fragmentation of networks requires the use of gateways to perform protocol conversion to unite merge networks at the top of the building automation control pyramid. End users must in turn manage complex systems.
Reasons for the existence of various communication networks include the need for longer distances, multidrop connectivity, powering scheme and support for unique protocols. Single-pair Ethernet (SPE) can address many of the above said reasons. Having Ethernet to the edge devices offers benefits such as direct accessibility for the control system, status updates, predictive maintenance, standardized hardware and interoperability across various systems.
Standard Ethernet uses simplex communication with independent cables for transmitting and receiving data, as Standard Ethernet Interface for 10/100 Mbps shows.
SPE is broadly classified into three categories:
IEEE 802.3.cg (10 Mbps)
IEEE 802.3.bw (100 Mbps)
IEEE 802.3.bp (1,000 Mbps)
IEEE 802.3cg has two more classifications:
Long and short cable lengths reach over a single balanced pair of either shielded or unshielded wire. 10BASE-T1L: IEEE 802.3 Physical Layer specification for a 10 Mb/s Ethernet local area network over a single balanced pair of conductors up to at least 1000 m reach (long reach using 18 AWG wire for point to point connection).
10BASE-T1S: IEEE 802.3 Physical Layer specification for a 10 Mb/s Ethernet local area network over a single balanced pair of conductors up to at least 15 m reach (short reach using 24–26 AWG wire with multidrop connection).
This article covers use cases for 10BASE-T1L, which offers up to 10 Mbps data rate over 1,000-m distances in building automation systems.
The 10BASE-T1L physical layer (PHY) operates using full-duplex communications over a single balanced pair of conductors with an effective data rate of 10 Mbps simultaneously in each direction. A 10BASE-T1L PHY, such as the DP83TD510E, uses three-level pulse amplitude modulation (PAM3), transmitted at 7.5 megabaud on the link segment. A 33-bit scrambler can help improve electromagnetic compatibility. MII transmit data (TXD<3:0>) are encoded together using four-binary three-ternary (4B3T) encoding, which keeps the running average (DC baseline) of the transmitted PAM3 symbols within bounds. Using the management data input/output interface to set the transmitter output voltage of the 10BASE-T1L PHY to 1.0 Vpp or 2.4 Vpp differentials will help achieve a longer communication distance over different cables.
As SPE Interface for 10 Mbps Using the DP83TD510E shows, SPE uses echo cancellation to achieve full duplex communication, along with multilevel signaling and equalization to improve signal quality and achieve the required data rate over a single-pair cable. There is no difference in the interface between the processor and the PHY; however, within the PHY, the transmit and receive sections of the Medium Dependent Interface require modification as outlined above to enable single-pair operation.
SPE also enables sending power over data lines (PoDL) along the same single-pair cable through a low-pass filter like the one shown in PoDL Example.
The table in the following image lists the various power classes supported by the IEEE 802.3.cg standard. The maximum power deliverable to the load is 52 W and is defined under Class 15. Power classes below 10 are covered by IEEE 802.3.bu.
Transitioning to SPE has multiple benefits, starting from installation to managing an entire building using a single communication network. Its benefits result in a lower total cost of ownership and a better return on investment in building automation systems. For example:
Having Ethernet connectivity brought to the edge eliminates the need for additional gateways, which simplifies systems by only requiring a single communication network.
PoDL eliminates the need for a separate power cable, which simplifies wiring in building automation systems.
With just one pair of wires, the cabling becomes cheaper and lighter, making overhead wiring easier.
Faster and easier installation reduces the cost of labor.
Improved bandwidth compared to existing field bus networks provides the flexibility to implement features such as predictive maintenance.
10BASE-T1L offering communication distance of 1000 m at 10Mbps data rate helps replace costlier fiber cables and enable more data transfer.
The following section explains how SPE can be implemented and the associated benefits for various building automation applications.