Conditioning a Switch-Mode Power Supply Current Signal Using TI OP Amps

1 Introduction

Switch-mode power supplies almost always require knowledge of the switching current, often sensed on the primary side of the power transformer. Current Sensing Solutions for Power Supply Designers⁽¹⁾ reviews many methods for sensing the switched current. In lower-power switch-mode power supplies, the method most often used employs a sense resistor. The type of sense resistor used is often a high power, low inductance resistor that can add significant cost and power dissipation to the power supply design. This circuit is shown in Figure 1-1 (a).

Figure 1-1 Typical R_Sense Method and Proposed Op-Amp Method for Sensing Primary Side Switch Current

To overcome the cost and power dissipation of such power resistors, the circuit of Figure 1-1 (b) is proposed. Using a differential amplifier made up of a low-power op amp and discrete resistors can result in several advantages including lower power dissipation (efficiency), noise immunity, cost, and programmability.

1. Current Sensing Solutions for Power Supply Designers, Bom Mammano, Unitrode Power Supply Seminar SEM-1200, 1997.

2 Circuit Design

A switch-mode power supply often switches current on the primary side of a transformer through a MOSFET and measures the primary current with a sense resistor (R_Sense) as shown in Figure 1-1 (a). The pulse width modulator IC (PWM) usually requires a current-sense signal (V_S) in order to provide short-circuit protection or for use in current mode control, or for both protection and control. The peak value of V_S depends on the PWM IC used, but it is typically 1 volt.

The value of the sense resistor R_Sense in Figure 1-1 (a) is chosen based on the peak value of the primary-side current (I_Peak) and the required value of V_S. Therefore, R_Sense is determined by:

R s e n s e = \frac{V s}{I p e a k}

The power dissipation in R_Sense is based on the RMS value of the primary-side current (I_rms), which depends on the peak value as well as on the waveshape and the duty cycle. The power dissipated is:

P s e n s e = {I r m s}^{2} \times R s e n s e

As an example, let:

I_Peak = 6.67 A

I_rms = 4 A

V_S = 1 V

These values result in an R_Sense of 0.15 Ω, and a power dissipation in R_Sense equal to 2.4 W. Typically, a 5-W-rated resistor would be used in this application.

The circuit of Figure 1-1 (b) can be used to significantly reduce the cost and power dissipation of R_Sense. First, let us review how the circuit of Figure 1-1 (b) operates. This op-amp circuit is configured as a typical differential amplifier. The circuit operates by multiplying the differential sense signal (V_Sense) by the differential gain of the op-amp circuit. If Rf = R3 and Ri = R2, this gain is:

G a i n = \frac{R f}{R i} a n d V s = V s e n s e x \frac{R f}{R i}

Using the previous example, assume that the design goal is to use a lower-power sense resistor with a standard value, such as a 0.01-Ω resistor rated at 0.5 W, and to limit the dissipation of this resistor to no more than 0.25 W. From this information, the gain of the circuit can be calculated.

P s e n s e = {I r m s}^{2} \times R s e n s e = {(4 A_{r m s})}^{2} \times 0.01 Ω = 0.16 W

V s e n s e = I p e a k \times R s e n s e = 6.67 A_{p k} \times 0.01 Ω = 66.7 m V

G a i n = \frac{V s}{V s e n s e} = \frac{1 V}{66.7 m V} = 15

Based on these results, let Rf = R3 = 15 kΩ and Ri = R2 = 1 kΩ in Figure 1-1 (b).

3 Advantages

Power Dissipation and Efficiency:

The power dissipation of the sense resistor (R_Sense) used in the second example results in an improvement of 2.4 W – 0.16 W = 2.24 W, which can result in a significant increase in efficiency as well.

Board Area:

The reduction in power rating results in a much smaller sense resistor. Consider for example the following sense resistors from Vishay Dale (www.vishay.com): WSR-3 3-W surface-mount and the WSL 1/2-watt surface-mount resistors. The 3-W device requires six times the board area of the 1/2 watt device and also needs significant copper area to dissipate the heat. The 1/2-W resistor combined with a SOT-23 op amp and sense resistors result in approximately the same overall board area. Therefore, there is no significant advantage or disadvantage in board area.

Cost:

The cost tradeoff in this design is not just the cost of a high-power resistor versus the cost of the lower-power resistor plus the op-amp circuit. The following considerations can also be made regarding cost:

Reduced bill of materials and reduced-size inventory: custom or semicustom power-supply designs often choose sense resistors for the particular peak current and sense voltage required for each design. This can result in each individual power supply design requiring a unique value and power rating, resulting in many sense resistors in the company’s inventory. By utilizing one standard component, such as a 0.01-Ω 0.5-W resistor, each individual power supply design can be customized by changing the gain of the resistors around the op amp circuit. This also helps cost by allowing volume buying of one resistor.
Through-hole construction versus surface mount: The cost of manufacturing large through-hole power resistors should be compared to that of manufacturing standard surface-mount components such as lower-power sense resistors, ICs, and standard SMD resistors.
Thermal: The cost of additional cooling due to higher power dissipation should be considered.

Programmability:

The peak current of the switch-mode power supply can vary due to minor design or output specification changes, or for various other reasons. The ability to easily adjust the gain of the op amp circuit offers power-supply designers easy programmability by allowing changes to the circuit performance without having to change the sense resistor. These changes can be due to control-loop changes, or to power supply specification changes such as input-voltage range or output-voltage and current changes, all of which affect the primary-side peak current.

Noise/performance:

Several factors of this op amp design will improve performance with regard to noise immunity of the sensed current signal:

Lower-inductance resistors: lower-power-rated resistors have smaller bodies and are almost always surface-mount devices. This results in significantly-less series inductance, producing less ringing and fewer noise spikes on the current signal.
Differential sensing: differential sensing of the current signal results in an accurate measurement of the primary-side current without the ground variation (ground bounce) becoming a factor. This is not the case in the circuit of Figure 1-1 (a), where the current sensing is single-ended.
Separating the grounds: the sense voltage (V_S) is often used by the PWM IC for both control and current limit protection. It is important to isolate the analog ground of the PWM IC from the noisy power ground of the sense resistor. The circuit of Figure 1-1 (b) allows the designer to use grounds that vary slightly. It also allows the power-supply designer to place the sense resistor away from the PWM IC using the op amp to buffer the signal. The op amp should be ground-referenced to the same analog ground as the PWM IC.