SLVAF11 June   2021 TPS51397A , TPS566231 , TPS566235 , TPS566238 , TPS568230

 

  1.   Trademarks
  2. 1Introduction
  3. 2Open Loop Frequency Response of D-CAP2 and D-CAP3 Converter
  4. 3Method to Choose LC Value for Loop Stability
    1. 3.1 Limits of Output Capacitance
    2. 3.2 Phase Margin Estimation Method
  5. 4Example of LC Design Method for D-CAP3 Converter
  6. 5Simulation and Experimental Verification
  7. 6Summary
  8. 7References
  9. 8Appendix A

Limits of Output Capacitance

In buck converters, the slope of open loop gain can be seen as -40dB/decade after double poles frequency ω0. When the ripple injection zero frequency ωRI is smaller than bandwidth, the loop gain will cross 0dB with -20dB/decade slope, as shown in Figure 3-1. Otherwise, it will cross 0dB with -40dB/decade slope, as shown in Figure 3-2.

GUID-20210220-CA0I-KDJD-3WTP-GRV5RJKRXTHN-low.gifFigure 3-1 Loop Gain of D-CAP2 Converter with -20dB/Decade at 0dB
Figure 3-2 Loop Gain of D-CAP2 Converter with -40dB/Decade Slope at 0dB

Assuming the loop gain drops with -40dB/decade slope after ω0, the cross frequency at 0dB is denoted as ωc. From Figure 3-1 and Figure 3-2, it’s known that Equation 7 is needed for a -20dB/decade cross.

Equation 7. GUID-20210220-CA0I-36VN-2RZP-9F4MHVCZ9HCD-low.gif

To calculate the frequency ωc, we can first get Equation 8 with ωc

Equation 8. GUID-20210220-CA0I-5LXT-ZCJ5-WJ0J0L2BCLKZ-low.gif

Then ωc can be derived as:

Equation 9. GUID-20210220-CA0I-MZJR-RCBB-KGNFCWH97G0R-low.gif

Substituting Equation 4 and Equation 9 into Equation 7, Equation 10 can be derived to ensure -20dB/decade cross.

Equation 10. GUID-20210220-CA0I-N764-CLMH-PG3BSCNRFC0S-low.gif

If further considering the DCR of inductor rL, Equation 10 will become:

Equation 11. GUID-20210220-CA0I-NTG5-LPLL-BNJXHHS85LF2-low.gif

Since the inductance L is normally designed with the target to let inductor current ripple be about 20%-40% of max load current rating. With Equation 10 or Equation 11, the upper limit of capacitance value can be got for loop stability.

In D-CAP2/D-CAP3 control, Acp and ωRI are the parameters determined by the internal circuit inside converters. Table 3-1 shows the Acp and ωRI of some devices with D-CAP2 or D-CAP3 control.

Table 3-1 Acp and ωRI of Several Devices
DeviceAcpωRI (fsw=600kHz)
TPS56823029.3270krad/s (43kHz)
TPS56623529.36198krad/s (31.5kHz)
TPS56623136247krad/s (39.3kHz)

Note: ωRI is already given in some data sheets (sometimes named as time constant, it's the reciprocal of ωRI). Acp of a device can be estimated by checking the gain before double poles, which equals to 20lg(Acp*Vref/Vo)dB in bode plot.

From Equation 11, it can be found that smaller output capacitor tends to bring a -20dB/decade cross. But too small output capacitance will make the double poles frequency too high and increase the bandwidth a lot. That may also cause insufficient phase margin, since the phase will drop apparently at high frequency range due to the effects of delay factor. For D-CAP2/D-CAP3 mode converter, normally the bandwidth needs to be limited below 1/3*fsw. That corresponds to a lower limit for output capacitance.

To get the limit, first we can get the loop gain at ripple injection zero in Figure 3-1 as:

Equation 12. GUID-20210220-CA0I-4VR7-QW0F-LDK6PB5DFC0H-low.gif

Loop gain will drop with -20dB/decade slope from ARI and cross 0dB at ωcross:

Equation 13. GUID-20210220-CA0I-NFXS-P7L4-SPPDCKHWX8X6-low.gif

Limit the crossover frequency below 1/3*fsw and the lower limit of output capacitance can be derived as Equation 15.

Equation 14. GUID-20210220-CA0I-MPB1-V2MN-XWTHSWR1H1P5-low.gif
Equation 15. GUID-20210220-CA0I-8BJ6-WW5F-V9D81XKZM4QJ-low.gif

Above all, the Equation 11 and Equation 15 are the upper limit and lower limit of output capacitance for loop stability.